Private Dining for ~10 - Best Recommendations?

Hello strangers!

It's been awhile, but I never forget who's got the real skinny on the dining scene. :) I am trying to organize a retirement dinner for a friend who has very high dining standards. Need space for approximately 10 people, quiet enough to have good conversation, and good food. We've got at least one pescatarian in the group, so seafood/veggie options are a must.

My current thoughts are:

Spoon and Stable

Burch Steak

112 Eatery

The Commodore – I know it has a private dining room, but it might be a bit big for our group. Anyone know?

Piccolo

Is there somewhere phenomenal that I'm missing? A lot of my favorite restaurants are tiny and not really condusive to private dining.

Thanks!