Honestly, I'm not sure if this exists, but I'm looking for a restaurant to take my father-in-law to for a pre-theater dinner on Saturday night. He is very picky about his eats: he likes very traditional American grub (grilled fish without a long ingredient list, chicken, steaks, meatloaf, pub food). We are looking for something cheap too; entrees all or mostly south of $20. Took him to Cafe Edison on his last visit and he enjoyed it. Coming in from Penn Station, so anywhere along the way from there would also be fine. The man does not like to walk or take the subway though, so we need somewhere relatively close to the theaters.