We will be in NYC for 1 night in August to see Hamilton. In an effort not to waste any of our short time there, we are staying at the W hotel near the theater, and we want to eat dinner nearby. I will be wearing heels and don't want to walk more than a block or two. We are considering Blue Fin because it's in our hotel, but I have read it's just okay. Thoughts on Blue Fin, Nios, Sardi's, Glass House Tavern? Would it be worth grabbing a cab to go to Oceana or somewhere else? Are cabs everywhere, easily hailed on a moment's notice? We're not interested in The View (ordinary expensive place) or R Lounge (small menu). All suggestions welcome.
Also appreciate recommendations for a nearby "quick but sit-down" breakfast the next morning.