I grew up in Queens near Brooklyn, so I have a lot of experience with good pizza. I moved to Binghamton, NY (a long story - it's great but the pizza is okay).
The best pizza I have ever had is along route 17, in middle of nowhere. Actually it's Parksville and Cooley New York, at a street light (one of very few on a real highway in NYS).
The man's from Staten Island, and his pizza, all eight or ten kinds is fabulous. Have you been there? Don't miss it on the way up to visit me from the City.
PS: If you want to visit my site, which has nothing to do with food per se, and a lot to do with Broome County (where I live), you may use this link.