Hello, really need help, coming to NYC for the first time over Easter for 5 days. I love to experience great food, my husband is a littel more reserved. I would rather best place to eat, vs. trendy tourist traps, places that the locals love. Looking for American, New American, Italian, Greek, Seafood. (too late for Babbo) and in the $$$ or the $$$$ range. Already have a reservation for Union Square Cafe, and we have two theatre nights. Really really need help, very confused, Zagats gives one review, and someone else shoots it down. Thanks a million.