Explore More Cities › +
Discover the unexpected in Outer Boroughs. Explore All of New York City
Restaurants & Bars 20

Peter Luger- Steak for 2 for 1 person

steakrules85 | May 29, 200805:09 PM

I want to preface this by saying I am no Luger virgin. I have been there many times and it is by far my favorite dining establishment in the world. I don't require a menu as most regulars don't. I know what I want. However, A couple of my 22 yr old buddies and I will be going there for a celebratory dinner and will be trying to accomplish something we have never tried. There will be four of us and I know me and my other friend are definitely going to try.... To devour the porterhouse for 2 all by ourselves.

I pride myself on being a steak lover and I know I can do it. Has anyone on the board ever accomplished the feat? If not I will glady take the leftovers home anyway since I can eat it everyday. The only question is do you think they will take issue with the fact that one person would try to order a steak for 2? I mean if we are willing to pay I am sure they would not care. And the other thing is we all like our steaks cooked differently- one likes it medium, one medium rare, one well done(I know don't get me started), and I am more of an in between rare and medium rare with a charred crust kinda guy,

However, I know over the past year there has been a huge shortage of beef, which is why they finally added the ribeye recently to the menu. I do not know how it is going to go down but we could possibly all order a steak for 2 just for ourselves making a grand total of 4 steak for 2's for 4 people. Gluttonous? Maybe so but we don't really care. It's our night out and our money. So the question is you think Luger will allow it? The only problem I can guess is space on the table for all that food lol. And yes we plan on also getting the bacon, fries, creamed spinac, onion rings, hot fudge sundae, etc. Really gunna be pigs and celebrate!

If worse comes to worse and for some reason they do not allow us to order steak for 2 for solo diners, I am thinking of just splitting a steak for 2 and a ribeye with my buddy since I always wanted to try it anyway. Wish me luck....ahhhh can't wait.

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›
Log In or Sign Up to comment

Recommended From CH