My husband and I (along with my 2 brothers) have reservations at Peter Luger's this week. However, we have heard and read that Robert's Steakhouse has excellent steak (best in New York according to Jeffrey Steingarten), and we have never been there. If anyone has tried both, we would be very interested to hear a comparison of quality and especially prices. (We heard that Robert's is even more expensive than Luger's, but haven't seen a menu.) Also, if the atmosphere is oppressive at Robert's, that would be helpful to know as well. We expect it will be a little nuts, but mostly want to be able to enjoy our steak.