My husband and I will be in Manhattan for our 7th wedding anniversary in mid-May and leaving behind our baby for the first time! We've been to NYC many times, but on this very short trip we have time for only one romantic dinner. We'd like to stick to our budget, so around $200 (we can splurge a bit if we're getting value). The one caveat is that I have an anaphylactic allergy to shellfish, and in the past some restaurants have discouraged me from even coming in when I call to make a reservation. Otherwise, we're open to all cuisines and especially interested in places that are under the radar. Thanks for any leads!