I have only been to the 74th street Fairway and while they have decent products the crowds are horrible. But the Pelham store is absolute great. The prices are so drastically low compared to other stores in lower Westchester and far lower than whole foods everywhere.
I was quite impressed with the store, as the shelves where stocked fully and the store was almost empty, my perfect store. It was pretty odd that the store was so empty considering the prices are so low, this was around 8.
Anyway, I am afraid this great store will close down if people don't shop there. So if you haven't tried it yet, please do. It is great.
Some price comparisons
I needed a bag of rye flour, same bah was $6 at WholeFoods(WF) in Columbus Circle and $3.19 at Fairway.
Box of wheat Gluten $7 at WF, $3.69 at Fairway.
My Toms deodorant $6 at WF, $3.99 at Fairway.