Since I have not had many kind words to say about Noe Valley Bakery in the past (though I have mostly tried pastries and cakes, which I think are mediocre there, not pies), I feel obligated to report that I recently had a peach and blackberry pie from there that was excellent! The filling was delicious, and the crust was eye-openingly good. It was served at a potluck and was a hit with all present. Lots of raves.
I don't know where the heck they got peaches and berries like that in February (Chilean fruit perhaps?) and they could have been, or pie could have been, previously frozen, but it certainly tasted fresh and I didn't think a crust could do that well after being frozen. (?). I believe the cost was $19.95. for a good size pie.
Noe Valley Bakery & Bread Co
4073 24th St, San Francisco, CA