This board has given a hard time to Otto over the past months.
I found the place to be extremely inviting. Great open decor. Pizza and pasta were both superb, and also priced extremely reasonably at $10 each. Gelato is some of the best I have had, and the olive oil gelato is particularly interesting.
Anyway, you could easily have a full meal for two here for $60, which makes this one of the best deals in New York right now.