+
Home Cooking

Why was my NY Strip tough? ;(

tangoking | Feb 24, 201612:58 AM     20

I cooked a birthday dinner for a friend tonight. I bought two NY Strip steaks from Wegmans: decent marbilization. Not prime, but a solid choice. About one inch thick.

I cooked them as follows: screaming hot cast iron skillet, two minute sear on each side. After the second sear, popped the entire skillet into a 350 degree oven for three minutes to finish them. Removed the steaks and let them rest for a bit; finished with a bit of butter and pepper.

They were perfectly medium-rare.. and they were TOUGH! My poor friend commented that he was going to go home and rest his jaw!

What gives? Did I do something wrong? Any ideas? I was really frustrated... It thought that everything was spot-on.

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

Recommended from Chowhound

Trending Discussions

3

Rhubarb, but not dessert?

Updated 12 hours ago 4 comments
5

April 2019 COTM Voting

Updated 9 hours ago 36 comments
Everything You Wanted to Know About Matcha Green Tea
Guides

Everything You Wanted to Know About Matcha Green Tea

by Joey Skladany | If your morning brew is in need of a green upgrade, look...

How to Eat So Well While Backpacking, It's Like You're Glamping
How To

How to Eat So Well While Backpacking, It's Like You're Glamping

by Amy Sowder | You're more hardcore than those sissy campers who require all the regular luxuries and a vehicle within...

Spring Roll Recipes That Are Perfect for Summer
Food News

Spring Roll Recipes That Are Perfect for Summer

by Joey Skladany | Spring has sprung again, but this time in the form of delicious and customizable spring rolls for...

The Ultimate Guide to Knives: When and Why We Use Each Type
Shop

The Ultimate Guide to Knives: When and Why We Use Each Type

by Greg Stegeman | The other day, I was in my kitchen cooking a meal and I needed to chop an onion. Indiscriminately...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.

See what's new!

View latest discussions ›