Home Cooking


Muffin Challenge -- Muffin #s 3 and 4


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Home Cooking 18

Muffin Challenge -- Muffin #s 3 and 4

Mrs. Smith | Nov 8, 2005 05:08 PM

Hi All,

Sorry about the inexcusably long time between reports, but i'm back baking muffins. To recap, the entries are

1 Oatmeal Apple Nut Muffins -- LisaN - scored a 16
2 Cranberry Muffins -- Smokey -- scored 16.5
3 Pumpkin Muffins -- Caitlin McGrath -- reviewed below
4 Auntie Bee's Cardamom Apricot Muffins -- reviewd below
5 Moist and Chocolatey Zucchini (Cake) Muffins -- Fun with Food -- TBD
6 Gold Grand Marnier (Cake) Muffins from the Cake Bible - Muffin -- TBD
7 Apple Bran Muffins -- Buttercup -- TBD
8 Muffin mix plus orange juice and orange zest -- Cyndy -- TBD
9 Doughnut Muffin from Fine Cooking -- Melissa -- TBD
10 Coconut Banana Muffins -- krissywats.

Again, cut and pasted from old threads, here are the scoring criteria

Minors: -- 1 possible point each.

1) Ease of mixing -- is it fussy, or easy?
2) Ease of ingredients -- are the ingredients easy to get, keep fresh, assemble?
3) Ease of baking -- easy to get in and out of the pan, bake well, uncomplicated?
4) Freeze well? Can you freeze or otherwise keep the muffin for about a week, possibly more?
5) Ease of defrostin -- post-freezing quality of the muffin.

Sooooo a perfect muffin would be a 20. HOWEVER, I reserve the right to....

-Even if a muffin scores a zero on all the minors, if the taste is so good, it can override a muffin that gets all five. Essentially, if the muffin is good enough, the baker (me) can through out all the minors and make them meaningless.

I just wanted to find a way to differentiate between these good muffins, assuming I like all of them the same in the taste department.

I also reserve the right to go back and change the score on a previous muffin, if I find, say 5 muffins into the challenge, that I've over or under scored.

The muffins will be tasted in these ways:

Fresh from the oven, just cool enough to eat
Cool, but still fresh (the next day)
After freezing for a few days, defrosted.

Ok, reviewing Caitlin McGrath's Pumpkin Muffins. I actually made these twice. Once in May before I moved, then again just last week (we're in the new house now and have internet connections, etc). This was because I lost my notes from the first bake in the move.

Caitlin, I don't really like pumpkin things. I know a lot of people who love pumpkin bread, muffins, cookies, etc, but I'm only so-so on it. Not the fault of these muffins, but they were handicapped from the start.

That said, they are good muffins, and I will keep them in my recipe file for when a pumpkin muffin becomes necessary :)

Taste: out of the oven -- 6 out of 10. A bit mealy and too pumpkinny for me, but certainly a good pumpkin muffin.
Texture: again, a bit too mealy. Very moist though which makes a big plus for me -- 4 out of 5

The minor scorings:

Mixing: 1 out of 1
Ingredients 1 out of 1
Baking: 1 out of 1
Freezing 1 out of 1
Defrosting 1 out of 1 (these freeze very well.)

TOTAL for Caitlins Pumpking Muffins: 15

Onto muffy's Auntie Bee's Cardamom Apricot Muffins.

I was really excited about these muffins, because I love the taste of cardamom. The problem with these adorable little muffins is that their cardamom flavor (only 1/8th teaspoon per 6 muffins) is VERY muted. I would up the cardamom in these just cause I like it.

Also, the dried apricots (this is a variation -- the original old-fashioned recipe has candied fruit, which I will also try separate from the challenge just because I want to!) were a revelation. I'm not wild about dried fruit in general but the apricot chunks were plump and delicious.

The problem was the texture. This is an old-fashioned creaming-method (cream softened butter and shugar together, as for a cake) muffin which makes for a slightly dry slightly tough muffin. The word is SLIGHTLY but still not as moist and fragrant as the Cook's Illustrated-endorsed melted-butter method. I also like that these are a 6-muffin recipe (very convenient to double) and the cinnamon icing (powdered sugar, milk, and cinnamon) is really really good. Why did I never think to add cinnamon to a powdered sugar glaze before?

Anyway, I wanted these to be the best muffin ever. They have potential, but there are few things wrong wtih it so I won't be able score it as high as I would like. Great, unique, muffin, though -- I will come back to it.

Taste -- only an 8 out of 10 because of the muted cardamom flavor.
Texture -- alas, a tiny bit too dry, and a bit too tough (I was careful not to over mix, it's just the creaming method) This is in comparison to an oil or a melted butter muffin, so I can't fault it since they are different animals. I just prefer a moister muffin (although this has a good traditional muffin texture) So, I'm sorry to say, a 3 out of 5

Onto the minors:

Mixing: fussy, creaming method. 0 out of 1
Ingredients: 1 out of 1
Baking: 1 out of 1
Frezing 0 out of 1 (apricots shrivelled, icing flaked)
Defrosting: 0 out of 1 (texture suffered)

I wish this muffin the best, though. It's a unique combination of flavors and is a perfectly acceptable muffin. It's just didn't wow me, which is what I'm looking for. Thanks, Muffy, however for the really interesting and special recipe.

Total: 13

Next up : Fun with Food's Moist and Chocolatey Zucchini Muffins!

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound