On a discussion about pizza in a thread below Wells Brothers in Racine led to Zaffiro's in Milwaukee. While researching Zaffiro's on the internet I found this link which is the Best of Milwaukee for 2003 in their city magazine.
I've raved about Kopp's frozen custard on here for three years while also really liking their hamburgers. (No, they're not In 'n Out but still good.) I've never heard anyone talk about Kopp's hamburgers. No one. Well, in looking down the list of Best of Milwaukee there is Kopp's listed for frozen custard. And for best hamburger!
And Zaffiro's for pizza which means that this year on my annual driving trip I have to somehow find the will to skip the Racine exist and go straight to Zaffiro's.
Of course Buca di Beppe is listed as Milwaukee's best Italian so...