my girlfriend and I are coming up to Milton from NYC to celebrate a 2 year anniversary (staying at the Buttermilk Falls B+B). I've done a bunch of searching on the board and have some ideas but could use any advice or recent updates, downhill alerts...we'll be there sunday and monday night and breakfast is covered by the inn. SO mainly looking for help with two nice dinners (or one "special" one and another informal one) and maybe a good lunch place. I've read about The Would which seems to get pretty good reviews here. also thinking about the Ship's Lantern Inn which is pretty close to our inn. Been thinking about the CIA (American Bounty?) also. We're mainly looking for a decently romantic place with great Hudson Valley inspired (or sourced I guess) food that's not super pricey (ie much more than $25-30 an entree)
thanks for any help you can offer!