I've been told by my father to make reservations anywhere I want for his birthday next week. We are seeing a show after on 45th and Broadway, so it needs to be within walking distance. There's just four of us, including a 13 year-old.
I know the restaurants along 9th Avenue very well, but not sure of what's more east of that (i try to avoid times square at all costs.) Italian/American/French/Japanese Cuisine preferable. Any rec's?