Mastro's is a very tough reservation. After several unsuccessful attempts, we were finally "blessed" with a reservation last night.
Conclusion: Huge disappointment. We'd never think of going there again.
The food: Worse than mediocre. We had the highly-touted "signature" steak. It was tasteless---really tasteless. We also had crabcakes, but they too were tastless. The mac and cheese was underwhelming.
The dessert (cheesecake) was ok, but not great.
The only thing that was good was the bread and butter.
Take the thoroughly ordinary food and combine it with a very noisy, cramped restaurant and you reach but one conclusion: Never again.