We are driving up from NYC to Martha's Vineyard for a weekend in early June and we were wondering where the must-eats are in the area. Since this is our first visit, we are looking for something iconic, delicious, and quintessential Martha's Vineyard. Something different from your typical NYC foodie fare or traditional french/new american restaurant. We won't have a car in the island though. Based on what I've read from Chowhound, here is the list I've come up with so far.
-Black Dog Tavern
-Larsen's Fish Market
-Art Cliff Diner
-Sweet Life Cafe or Mediterranean (which one is better?)
-Offshore Ale (only for beer)
Also, it would be great if you have recommendations on where to stop on the way from NYC to MV and back.