Home Cooking

Cakes Pound Cake

Making a pound cake with zero experience and a dorm oven.


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Home Cooking 5

Making a pound cake with zero experience and a dorm oven.

theannerska | Feb 3, 2008 08:52 PM

Hi all,

My first attempt at baking from scratch -- an ordinary pound cake -- spectacularly failed tonight. I could really use any and all the help I can get! Please help me out here, I'd really like to make this for Valentine's Day and am working with the old oven in my dorm "kitchenette." I'm sure a number of things went wrong, but I'm not quite sure what, and this was not the optimal first-time experience I had in mind.

- First, the recipe called for a 10" tube pan but I googled to see whether I could use a loaf pan instead (I want a pound cake in that traditional loaf shape). I've got a 9"x5" loaf pan and most sources suggested substituting 2 loaf pans for 1 10" tube pan, so I figured I could just split the recipe in half and use one loaf pan. Is that just a recipe for disaster?

- But maybe the disaster resulted from overfilling it -- I filled it up about 2/3 in the pan and it completely overflowed in the oven. Since I've never baked before, I don't even know how this part is supposed to look. Should I stick to halfway up the pan, even if there's batter left over?

- Upon the emergency evacuation from the oven, the "cake" resembled something between liquid and solid, with some over-browned edges/top. Would those edges have just burned completely black if the rest of the cake finished baking? How does one avoid this (i.e., with a lower oven temp maybe)?

- Lastly, I now have a container full of the cake innards -- all the semi-liquid stuff from the pan. Is it safe to let this get to room temp, refrigerate, and re-bake? Or just eat cold (kind of like a pudding)? Should I just let this one go and throw it out?

I cook often and have never had problems making substitutions for normal food recipes -- should I avoid this in the future with baking? I never thought this would be such an epic failure! I'm pleading for your help here, 'hounds. Please restore my faith in baking (and self-esteem). Thanks in advance.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound