Grew up in the area, we're all moved away, but we're having a christening in Shoreham in June, and are looking for a restaurant for a nice meal afterwards. Years ago I used the private room upstairs at Sea Basin for a wedding rehearsal dinner, and was thinking that might work... but their website is broken right now and I can't see the current menu/pricing or if it's even open. We need a menu that appeals to diverse, more basic tastes. This is not a gourmet crowd, and needs to offer fairly simple American or Italian food at a decent price point. We'd really prefer a place with a private room, because we'll have 7 children... most of them 5 and under. After the last big family event we had in the area, Deks is off the list because despite confirmations, when we showed up, they weren't expecting us. We don't want to go much further East or West, and are hoping to find a place that meets this criteria.
Caruso's was one place that was mentioned. Any opinons on Caruso's or other suggestions?