Went to John's on Bleecker Street tonight. Got two pies. They were not only not good, they weren't even mediocre. They were just plain bad. Crust was too soggy. Tomato sauce was sickeningly sweet. Various topping (shrooms, sausage, onions and peppers) were average.
I haven't been here in years but figured it was still good, based on the long lines and the occasional praise on here. Were these pies just an aberration?