To settle the questions, I called the Orleans Branch and was told they get their bagels from A&F on Long Island. I am off Cape but was at the Brewster branch quite a bit in June..it wasn't so amazing in fact the first time was so bad I called the Orleans manager to share my experience. The bagel was soft and white and doughy...not good. service was so so but they were a new location so that's to be expected.. I prefer the Orleans location. It's chill and cozy and hip. The new location is rather odd...a combined high end sort of beach boutique on one side and stark open bagel place on the other. The Placement of oddly selected leather furniture in the middle is strange...a few nice Adirondeck chairs on the lovely spacious entry way...time will tell what transpires here after the tourists leave...I guess I really don't get why they'd put another location 3+ miles from their main location? Why not have one in Dennis, where we need a bagel place. Perhaps the Brewster location is seasonal? I have been a HUGE JM Orleans fan for years and will continue to be..