Restaurants & Bars

Los Angeles Area Dessert

Jar last night-- a tale of two desserts


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 4

Jar last night-- a tale of two desserts

alla giudia | Mar 16, 2006 12:08 PM

Wound up unexpectedly at Jar last night (called from around the block at 9:30p and they took three of us right away--with no attitude!) and I wanted to report here because we tried two desserts that I'd seen mentioned on this board.

As most of yall probably know, Jar operates in the classice steakhouse with a twist genre. To that end, I'd say my starter, the iceberg wedge w blue cheese, was more classic than twisty, and good-not-great, but what can they do with it really? a mood thing. The "signature" potroast, however, was stellar. Everything a comforting, meaty p-roast should be and much, meltingly, delicously more. The other dish I tried, the green garlic soup w no cream that my s.o. ordered, seemed to me to exist out of the steakhouse genre entirely-- more something you'd eat at the home of a particularly good and adventurous vegetarian chef, albeit one who used chicken stock. Very spicy-exotic. I thought of s'wan peppercorns but only I'm sure because of yesterday's Times article, and not because I really tasted them.

Anyway, the desserts: one best in show, one worst.

Worst first--the banana cream pie. I am a big bcp fan and this was a big disappointment. Instead of a nice slice out of the fridge, what we got was an individual pie in a premade tart-shell. Butter crust was all wrong for bcp, and wouldn't have been great even with a lemon tart. Filling was too soft too mild-flavored and too hard to distinguish from the whip cream topping. In a word, this pie was bad, and I don't mean badass, I mean bad. I even prefer the "deconstructed" banana cream pie I ate out of a glass not long ago at Blair's (where --usually-- the desserts totally rock.)

Speaking of desserts in a glass, our other dessert at Jar, recommended by a hound recently, was the butterscotch pudding-- not on the regular menu but a special. Now this was a dessert. Out of this world good. In every way as great as the bcp was bad. The consistancy was more pot de creme/ or mousse-like than diner pudding like. But that was fine with me because it wasn't too light and foamy. It had just enough density. Really a great texture. But the flavor-- man, it was perfect. Intense butterscotch deliciousness that didn't stray too far from the flavor of the jello butterscotch pudding I remember from childhood, but at the same time was much much better. A butterscotch pudding made by someone who knows how to make a killer creme caramel but chooses instead to do the pudding, and really do it. The pudding came topped with a dulce de leche/ cahete (sp?) type caramel sauce that ribboned into the pudding when you dipped your spoon in. Heaven.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound