I had a burger at Island burger and shakes/ 9th ave + 51st , yesterday for lunch and I must say that I heard so many good things about it but I was disappointed by the service.
it just seemed like the 2 waiters were un attentive to me. Maybe because I was by myself but I had to ask for everything twice and they seemed cold.
I enjoyed the burger though and would go back again with some more people and try it again.
Trying to have a burger at Peter Lugers this week and at McHales Bar and possibly the cornor bistro too.