I'm trying to plan a private dinner party for my dad's 75th birthday, and Harvest on Hudson looks like it has a really nice menu. The reviews seem so mixed -- I'm wondering if people are forgiving bad food for good views. The dinner would be at night in the winter, so the view wouldn't be so important. The food is important, though.
If anyone has any additional suggestions in Westchester, Bergen or Manhattan -- Dad's tastes run to Felidia's, but my bank account would like me to stay in the 50pp range. Looking to host 20-25 people (all adults) in a private dining room.