I lived in NY about five years ago and I used to LOVE Grange Hall on Commerce. Every year I try to make it back to NY at least once or twice and always eat at Grange. Last visit I heard it had gone down hill-----too crowded, messy service etc. I tried it for lunch and sure enough it was pretty terrible. I am coming back to NYC next week and would love to know if I should bother going for dinner at Grange at all----or if someone knows something similar. Thanks for your help everyone!!