Last night my husband and I had what would have to be be considered a so-so dinner at Gotham Bar & Grill. The menu reads well but upon tasting, the food was not as interesting. Don't get me wrong, there were no major problems: both our entrees were properly cooked. It's just that the whole experience was, well, flat. Service was disinterested at best - we waited a good while until the waiter showed up, took a long time for the wine to arrive, that sort of thing. When we got the bill we felt ripped off: we did not order an extravagant wine ($39) but the tab (2 apps, 2 entrees, wine, no dessert or coffee) was $180 before tip. Clearly not value for money.
Question for others: is our experience typical or did we just hit the place on an off night? I would certainly never recommend it to anyone based on last night.