My dad sent me a box of caramels from a candystore in Indianapolis called Abbott's Also. (apparantly their original store opened in Hagerstown, IN in 1890). These things were so good...so rich and buttery. about the texture of taffee. I finished them the other night, and I thought I ought to share. No website, but they do mail order, and they have an email address: AbbottsAlso@yahoo.com
They have chocolates, cordials, peanut brittle and all that too.