I am looking for a good date spot for a second date with a girl I really like. Ideally, it will be somewhat dark and not too loud, and a good place to have a good conversation.
I don't want to get too close to the center of the island, so best-case scenario would be somewhere between 40-60 streets, on Lexington or east of that, but that is not an absolute necessity.
As far as food, Italian would be great, or something eclectic and interesting. No sushi, though.
Please, any suggestions are MUCH APPRECIATED!