Being the type of person to try and stay away from chains...I frequent these and I would recommend you try the following restaurants in Geneva.
Foxfire - great steaks, my fave is the horseradish crusted filet mignon....AWESOME!
Stockholms - great for lunch type fare....the filet mignon sandwich is divine! When they have the ultimate steak sandwich on special you have to try that one too!
Old Towne Pub - when you are in the mood for buffalo wings...this is the place, Every Wednesday is wing night, $.30 wings....their other food is okay I only go for the wings!