Restaurants & Bars

Boston Area Dinner

full dinner at Sibling Rivalry


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 2

full dinner at Sibling Rivalry

MC Slim JB | Nov 23, 2004 08:06 AM

Finally got a sit-down meal in the dining room here, after a couple of snack and dessert visits. Short version: very respectable food, with emphasis on pretty platings, at the high end of the South End fine-dining price spectrum. Many more hits than misses. Standouts at our table: apps -- pumpkin ravioli in brown butter and fried sage, a Mexican-style tuna soup (sounds odd, but was extraordinary); entrees -- a veal chop, a cylinder of boned short ribs; sides -- a gratin of flageolets with sausage (a $6 mini-cassoulet).

Foie gras terrine app was pretty good; composed salad with roasted pear just so-so. Wine list has the increasingly typical and annoying high-end tilt: most are in the $70-to-$90 range, but we found some bargains at >$40, notably a $40 Oregon pinot noir, a much better value than the $32 Italian Barbera. Desserts are good but not swoony; I'm learning to expect homemade ice creams to be outstanding, and they're merely very good here.

At this price point, I find two things rather odd. The dining room is pedestrian verging on ugly, with a seafoam and autumn pastel palette that sreams "businessman's hotel dining room" to me. Service is young, attractive, and somewhat unpolished; pleasant and attentive on a busy night, but obviously not very seasoned. How many wine bottles must you open before it looks like it's not a puzzle, or pour before you can hit the glass with accuracy? (Good stemware, though.)

The crowd is odd for the neighborhood, too (or maybe just represents the new South End): older, suburban-looking, decidedly unfunky.

Soup to nuts with about four glasses of modestly-priced wine, tax and tip works out to about $80/person. Neither a steal nor a swindle for a celebratory meal; we're all pretty happy with the experience. I doubt if any of us could recall or care which brother's side of the menu (chef Bob vs. chef Dave) our dishes came from.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound