+
Food Media

What US food critics could learn from the UK (and vice versa, I guess …)

Melanie Wong | Mar 11, 202008:32 PM     7

" . . . But we do that job very differently. 'US critics write as if they are the inheritors of the mantle of Tom Wolfe or Hemingway,' says Giles Coren, who reviews for the Times in the UK. 'They go five times. There’s a pomposity to the way they write.'

Sam Sifton, the food editor of the New York Times, who was also the paper’s critic for two years between 2009 and 2011, returns the compliment. British restaurant critics can be 'barbaric', he says, although he admits to finding it all highly entertaining. 'For the reader, there’s something delicious about you lot going off on some horrible place. As a reader I take delight in that. We, however, have to take a more sombre approach.'

Indeed they do. Travelling across the US, undertaking research for my latest book on my last meal on earth, which draws on my 20 years as a restaurant critic, I was constantly struck by the difference in tone. . . "

What US food critics could learn from the UK (and vice versa, I guess …)

American and British restaurant reviews could hardly be more different in tone: on one hand respectful and august, on the other savage and irreverent

www.theguardian.com
Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

Invite a friend to chime in on this discussion.

Email a Friend

More from Chowhound

21 Tropical Touches to Turn Your Place into Paradise
Home

21 Tropical Touches to Turn Your Place into Paradise

by Jen Wheeler | With coronavirus making travel a tricky and even potentially dangerous prospect this year, we're embracing...

8 Global Online Cooking Classes for a Taste of Travel at Home
Shop

8 Global Online Cooking Classes for a Taste of Travel at Home

by Pamela Vachon | With coronavirus making travel a tricky and even potentially dangerous prospect this year, we're embracing...

The Hawaiian and Not-So-Hawaiian Histories of the Mai Tai
Spotlight Interviews

The Hawaiian and Not-So-Hawaiian Histories of the Mai Tai

by Paige Feldman | With coronavirus making travel a tricky and even potentially dangerous prospect this year, we're embracing...

11 Pineapple Drinks That Go Beyond Piña Coladas
Recipe Round-Ups

11 Pineapple Drinks That Go Beyond Piña Coladas

by Jessica Gentile | With coronavirus making travel a tricky and even potentially dangerous prospect this year, we're embracing...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.