Restaurants & Bars

Fish Tacos

Fish Tacos in Bellport, Long Island


Restaurants & Bars 11

Fish Tacos in Bellport, Long Island

Dave Feldman | Sep 9, 2006 06:56 PM

I visited the Sugar Loaf Cafe in downtown Bellport. I was looking primarily for good iced coffee, and I found it here. The baked goods were better than average. So when I made a second visit, and did a little spying, I figured out that not only the cook, but the owner, was Mexican. That explains why the menu, which is heavy on "gourmet" sandwiches, wraps, and salads, also featured soft tacos -- chicken, beef, shrimp, or mahi-mahi.

I was in the mood for fish tacos. What I didn't expect was beautifully grilled fish with a pungent cabbage and carrot slaw. The toppings weren't traditional -- a carrot and orange vinaigrette with cilantro and lime mayo. The result was delicious, even with standard-issue institutional, tasteless flour tortillas.

I spoke to the owner and complimented him on the tacos. He's a Chowhound, no doubt, who frequently goes to Westchester to eat Mexican. Along with an ice cream place a block away that serves Double Rainbow ice cream, I'd rather eat at Sugar Loaf than, say, Spicy's, as much as I'd want the barbecue to be better there.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound