My search has been rewarded. There's a great little pizza shop called NY Style Pizza right in downtown Framingham on Concord St (route 126). I dropped in Saturday, just for a slice. There was a plain pie coming out of the oven, so that is what I had. The crust was nice and thin, not soggy. The sauce was sweet and tomato-y, could have used a little more salt and pepper, but I did that myself. The cheese was great-- nice and bubbly and evenly melted, not too greasy.
I need to go back and try some toppings. I am assuming a re-heat slice will be just as good as th eone I had, and given it was just out of the oven I am sure a whole pizza will also be great.