Here's my final 5 for my date Thursday night:
Here are my concerns: Locanda and Angelini are above my budget, and Angelini doesn't have a great atmosphere. Cafe Veneto sounds great, but is it a major step down down from the quality of Locanda? Pastis is a complete unknown, which is also a plus. Vivoli is great, fits within the budget, but I personally wouldn't mind trying something new. I've only been to Vivoli on this list, so I know that I could be in for an awesome culinary experience with any of the others.