The husband's birthday is coming up, and he wants pie. I would ordinarily make it myself, but I'm going to be crazy at work at the same time. So, where can I get the best Old Fashioned Apple Pie in Manhattan? East Side a plus, 40's through 60's even bigger plus. He has said that he doesn't want anything with a "weird granola crust" (No sour cream apple walnut from Little Pie Company). Does Buttercup make good pies? Help!