Home Cooking


Entries closed and received for the Muffin Challenge


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Home Cooking 11

Entries closed and received for the Muffin Challenge

Mrs. Smith | Mar 9, 2005 01:15 PM

Hello all muffin bakers,

Thanks to all the people who responded to my "Make me a muffin-- A Chowhound Challenge" thread. I am pleased to say I have received many good suggestions, and I'm ready to close entries (at least for the time being) and begin recipe and taste testing.

The entries are:

1 Oatmeal Apple Nut Muffins -- LisaN
2 Cranberry Apple Muffins -- Smokey
3 Pumpkin Muffins - Caitlin McGrath
4 Cardamom-Apricot Muffins -muffy
5 Moist and Chocolatey Zucchini (Cake) Muffins -- FunwithFood
6 Golden Grand Marnier (Cake) Muffins from the Cake Bible - Muffin
7 Apple Bran Muffins -- Buttercup
8 Muffin mix plus orange juice and orange zest - Cyndy
9 Doughnut Muffins from Fine Cooking -- Melissa
10 Coconut Bananna Muffins -- krissywats

Eliminated from competition (at my discretion -- sorry folks!):

Pomegranate Ginger Muffins -- thank you, creepygirl, for the enry, but I can't get pomegranate seeds but a few months of the year, plus I don't really like sweet ginger things. This might be a fab muffin, but it's just not right for my everyday morning pastry

Cranberry Buckwheat Muffins -- I've had a buckwheat muffin before (my sister is mad for them) and I seriously object to the texture, so I'm sorry, Rita, I won't be making these. Thanks very much for the entry

Various Joy of cooking muffins -- kbl. Thanks, kbl, for the idea, but I've baked all of the JOC muffin recipes and none of them wowed me.

Ok, now that we have the chosen few (wow -- a field of 10! I never thought I'd get more than 3-5!), I will start baking. This may take me several months, actually, to bake through all of them. I may make two recipes side by side and freeze them and alternate eating them, but probably never more than 2 at a time. With 12 muffins in each batch (except 6 for cardamom-apricot) and 10 recipes, by consumption rate of 1 per day, well, you do the math! It may be late summer before I'm through.

But I, as a loyal Chowhounder, promise I will bake through all of these recipes. I've reviewed them and they all have ingredients that I can get readily (yes, I found sources for flaxmeal and pumpkin butter!) and that I think I would enjoy making and eating.

The proud winner will be presented with a Cooking.com gift certificate from me, and I will discuss my results on this board, for any who are interested in this bake-off!

I really appreciate all the entries. I look forward to some extraordinary muffin experiences in the near future!

Link: http://www.chowhound.com/topics/show/...

Want to stay up to date with this post?