Husband and I have family coming into town for the holiday. In an attempt to appease all tastes, we are are spending the day checking out the early Blue Man Group show Friday and then want to get a good meal afterward. 5 adults for dinner, mature group with one vegetarian.
Open to driving to another area of town where parking is accessible, but walking further than 5 or 6 minutes from parking/the theater is not ideal. Valet is okay, too. Reservations highly needed as waiting around for a table won't be manageable. However, don't want to break the bank on dinner and drinks.
Already considered Teatro (couldn't get reservation online through open table), Island Creek Oyster (booked), Market by Jean-Georges (pricey? worth it?).
Would love some suggestions for a comfortable dining atmosphere with a low volume level for easy conversations.