I've decided to start a new thread, since the last one has been around since 2007, and it's way too big @ this point.
As a self-described doughnut connoisseur, these are, what I believe to be the best doughnuts in the city:
1. Emma's Country Kitchen: Maple Bacon Doughnut
2. Glory Hole: Banana Cream Pie
3. Paulette's: Plain Cake Doughnut/Pumpkin Pie Doughnut (Seasonal)
4. Emma's Country Kitchen: Cinnamon Sugar Doughnut
5. Epi's: Plain Sugar Doughnut