I had dinner there last week and I think that this pub is not given enough attention. The fireplace was crackling and I was lucky to get a table in one of the stained glass alcoves. The decor has always reminded me of the old timey bars in upstate NY and is warm and charming.
The burger of course, was excellent, beefy and well portioned, juicy and straightforward. The fish and chips was fresh and a wonderful hearty portion, although not as good as Chip Shop, the best F&C I've had in a pub. Charming ambiance and good food for almost $20, all and all my favorite pub in NYC.