Hi Chowhounds!! Dinner tonight with the parents before a show at the Helen Hayes theater. They are coming in to Penn Station and do not like to go too far out of their way - they want Virgil's b/c it's right next door to the theater. But we went there last time! I'm drawing a blank, and nothing in that neighborhood is really "sending" me. Can someone help by recommending a hidden gem in the Theater District or Midtown West? Or, I think I could make a case to the folks for something not far from a train that they could get at Penn Station. (I want Jacque-Imo's, but I know that two blocks West of Broadway will get veto-ed!!).
Thanks in advance for the help!