My husband and I will be celebrating our 10th anniversary of dating (I know, at this point people only celebrate their wedding anniversaries, but it is 10 years!) and it'll be the first time out after the birth of our baby 6 weeks ago. We are going to leave her at a friend's house in Fort Greene, so we are looking for a place that isn't so far from there, as we want to spend most of our time celebrating and not driving! We would also like to try some new place (new for us), which isn't so hard as we barely went out while I was pregnant as I was very sick, and we don't go out in Fort Greene much anyway. So, I am leaning towards ICI, where we've been meaning to go, but I would like to hear opinions on the choice. Would Locanda Vini e Olii be better? What about the place in Prospect Heights that have the same owners as 360?
We are not looking for super fancy or anything; just a really good meal in a nice environment that allows for conversation. Thanks!