We'll be in NYC for 3 nights next month and need a dinner spot for one of the nights. Two of the nights are predetermined...we'll be taken to Gramercy Tavern and cannot come to NYC without eating at our fave, Union Square Cafe (another of Danny M's places). For our 3rd night we're considering Red Cat where we've been several times and love, or trying out Public which would be new to us, and looks interesting. We'd like American, French or seafood...but nothing too stuffy. Ideally, not too loud. Any thoughts. Is Public a good choice, or...?