My husband and I had a wonderful experience at Colvin Run Tavern for his birthday in the spring. The food and the service were both fabulous.
We're going back for our anniversary next month, and reading this board, I see that some people had disappointing service there. A couple people mentioned it may depend on the room and the server. Could you tell me which room and server to request and which to avoid? Unfortunately, I can't remember which room we were in last time, though my husband may (it might have been Chesapeake, and I'm sure it wasn't Nantucket).