I know its a little late in the summer for this but the gelato stand outside of Circo on 55th and 6th is suprisingly fantastic (suprising given the fact that the restaurant has sucked forever) the guys told me its all homemade. Some interesting flavors today were basil and blood orange. My usual chocolate, creme brulee and pistachio was fantastic. If Giuletti's in Rome is a 10, Otto is an 7 1/2 this gelato is a 7. And to to top it off a small is $2 and medium is 3$, its cheaper than crapass mister softee!!