My wife and I live in NY and are planning a 4 day trip to a Caribbean island during mid-January. There are so many good islands that it has been hard for us to decide, so looking for recommendations based on our below preferences (this is our first trip to Caribbean).
1. Good "Scuba dive" experience
2. Beaches - We want to spend time relaxing, so not looking something crowded.
3. Last but definitely not the least - "Food" I love food and would like to experience some authentic sea food.
Thanks in advance for any help possible.
A and V