Hi. My wife and I next weekend are going out for an anniversary dinner in Cape May and are considering Tisha's and the Black Duck? I'm both concerned about the food -- as a Chowhound who isn't? -- and the setting, as so many restaurants in Cape May seem, from photos on their website, to be very formal and more than a little pretentious.
So far, I have narrowed my choices down to Tisha's and the Black Duck. Any opinions are greatly appreciately. Per Tisha's, if anyone has any advice on eating on the patio vs inside, that would be welcome too.
Any other recommendations are also welcome.