Yet another Brooklyn catering query

So to add to the clamor for Brooklyn caterers: My partner and I are planning a 10th anniversary shindig for this summer, and are presently looking for caterers. The first place we've actually been able to get a price quote from (Naturally Delicious, in Carroll Gardens) would end up costing us $75-100 a head when all the costs are added in, which is a bit out of our price range unless we sell the cats into slavery.

We're not looking for anything lavish, just tasty food that won't poison our guests. Anyone have any ideas, or should we just give up and invite everyone over to our house for fondue?

Neil