Thank you to all who offered suggestions and guidance.
We ate at Bistro Zinc in Lenox which I would do all over again. Service was good, surround was warm and food better than both!!
Spigalina in Lenox was a HUGE disappointment. The prices were akin to Zinc and really not in keeping with the quality of what was served. I would avoid it big time.
Old Inn on the Green in New Marlboro was the absolute highlight. Superb service, stellar food, great wine list and lovely atmosphere. I suggest folks mapquest it tho as finding it in the dark was a challenge even with mapquest.