I've seen ads of late for a new BBQ place in Mahopac called Holy Smoke. I stopped by today to check out the menu, and wish I could report on the food there but I didn't get a chance to eat (and I don't eat beef/pork so I am far from an expert and my opinion would not be worth much). But the menu looks interesting, and they had some interesting looking chicken dishes, so we will definitely check in out in the coming weeks. Hopefully someone who is more of an authority on BBQ will try it and let us know how it is. Oh, and since I see there is an earlier thread here asking about pit BBQ, I should say that this place says they are pit BBQ.
It's on Route 6N (they claim in their ads to be 2.6 miles east of the Taconic, Route 6 exit), where Heidi's used to be.
There had been a BBQ place in Mohegan Lake until recently (Smokey's, I believe) but they are closed. I'm assuming this new place is not related.
Phone number - 845-628-9795. If anyone has questions about the menu I'd be happy to answer them since I took a copy with me.